A Senior’s Guide to Orthotics for High Arches

High arches might sound fancy, but they can make your feet feel like they’ve been in a bar fight. If walking feels like a chore and your feet ache just from standing, you're in the right place. We'll break down why your feet are so dramatic and how simple inserts can bring some peace and quiet.

So, What's the Deal with High Arches?

A high arch (doctors call it pes cavus) is when the middle of your foot is raised way up off the ground. Your foot is supposed to work like a tripod, spreading your weight evenly. With high arches, all your weight slams down on just two spots: your heel and the ball of your foot.

As you get older, the natural fat pads in your feet, your built-in cushions, start to thin out. This is a double whammy for high-arched feet, which already put a ton of pressure on those two spots. The cushioning disappears right when you need it most.

Why Do They Hurt So Much?

This pressure party leads to some nasty problems. Plantar fasciitis is that sharp, stabbing pain in your heel, especially in the morning. Metatarsalgia is the burning ache in the ball of your foot.

High-arched feet also tend to roll outward with each step (a motion called supination). This makes your ankles wobbly and unstable. For seniors, that instability seriously increases the risk of rolling an ankle and taking a dangerous fall.

How Insoles (Orthotics) Actually Work

A good orthotic doesn't just add cushion, it fixes the real problem of pressure and alignment. Think of your high arch as a bridge with no middle support. An orthotic slides in to fill that gap, allowing your whole foot to share the load.

This simple fix immediately takes the pressure off your overworked heel and forefoot. It provides a more even and balanced base for your entire body.

High-arched feet are also terrible shock absorbers. Every step sends a jolt up your legs to your ankles, knees, and hips. Good insoles are made of materials that soak up that shock, protecting your joints and making walking way more comfortable.

Your feet are the foundation for your whole body. When they roll outward, it throws your ankles, knees, and even your back out of whack. A good orthotic corrects that roll at the source, which helps align everything else and leads to better balance.

Picking Your Weapon: Types of Insoles

The world of orthotics can seem a bit much, but the choices really boil down to three main types.

The Drugstore Aisle: Soft Cushions

You can find these cheap gel or foam insoles everywhere. They add a bit of cushion, which is nice for mild foot fatigue. But they're squishy and don't offer real support, so they won't fix the pressure problems from high arches.

The Sweet Spot: Semi-Rigid Orthotics

This is where most people with high arches find relief. Semi-rigid orthotics have a firm but flexible shell that supports your arch, plus a comfy foam top layer. They give you the best of both worlds, real support without feeling like you have a rock in your shoe.

Some are designed with a deep heel cup to stop your foot from rolling, while others focus on full-contact support under the arch. Both are good approaches for stabilizing the foot and relieving pain.

The Big Guns: Custom Orthotics

If your pain is severe or you have other foot issues, you might need custom orthotics from a podiatrist. They'll scan or cast your foot to make an insert that's a perfect match for you.

They're expensive (think $300 to $800), but their perfect fit can provide life-changing relief. Sometimes Medicare can help cover the cost, especially for seniors with diabetes.

What to Look For in a Good Insole

Knowing the parts of an insole helps you pick a winner. Each piece has a job to do.

A Deep Heel Cup

This is super important for stability. A deep heel cup holds your heel's natural fat pad in place (your body's own cushion!) and stops your ankle from rolling outward. Less wobble, fewer falls.

Semi-Rigid Arch Support

Again, avoid super soft insoles that just squish down. You need a "semi-rigid" support. It's strong enough to hold up your arch but has a little flex so it feels natural when you walk.

Good Materials

Look for high-density foam (often called EVA foam), it's cushy but doesn't flatten out after a week. Some insoles also have gel pads in the heel and forefoot for extra shock absorption. A soft top cover is nice too, as it helps prevent blisters.

Metatarsal Pads (Maybe)

Got a burning pain in the ball of your foot? Look for an insole with a metatarsal pad. It’s a little dome-shaped bump that sits behind the ball of your foot, and it helps spread the bones out to relieve pressure on the nerves there.

How to Use Your New Insoles

Getting the right orthotics is step one. Using them correctly is step two.

Take It Slow

Don't just jam them in your shoes and go for a 5-mile walk. Your feet need to get used to the new support. Wear them for an hour or two the first day, then add about an hour each day.

Make Them Fit

This is key: take out the flimsy insole that came with your shoe first. Putting your new orthotic on top of the old one will make your shoes too tight and unstable. If you need to trim your new insole, use the old one as a template to trace and cut.

Pair Them with Good Shoes

Even the best insole can't fix a terrible shoe. Use your orthotics in shoes that are sturdy. Look for footwear with a firm heel, enough room for your toes, and laces or straps you can tighten for a snug fit.

Works cited

1. High Arch Feet (Pes Cavus): Causes, Symptoms & Treatment, https://my.clevelandclinic.org/health/diseases/high-arch-feet-pes-cavus
2. Pes Cavus - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK556016/
3. High Foot Arches: Complete Guide to Causes, Symptoms, and Treatment, https://thefootpractice.com/foot-ankle/high-foot-arch/
4. The Ageing Foot - Physiopedia, https://www.physio-pedia.com/The_Ageing_Foot
5. Heel Pain- It's Not Always Plantar Fasciitis, https://certifiedfoot.com/heel-pain-not-always-plantar-fasciitis/
6. Pain in the Ball of the Foot (Metatarsalgia) | My Doctor Online - Kaiser Permanente, https://mydoctor.kaiserpermanente.org/ncal/structured-content/pain-in-the-ball-of-the-foot-metatarsalgia-66157
7. Orthotics for Metatarsalgia - PrimeCare, https://primecareprosthetics.com/conditions/metatarsalgia
8. Coping with the changes your feet undergo as you age | UCLA Health, https://www.uclahealth.org/news/article/coping-with-the-changes-your-feet-undergo-as-you-age
9. Foot Arch Differences in Elderly People at Standing: Considering Gender and Age, https://www.rehabilityjournal.com/articles/jnpr-aid1005.php
10. Anatomy and Biomechanics of Cavovarus Deformity | Request PDF - ResearchGate, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/332161156_Anatomy_and_Biomechanics_of_Cavovarus_Deformity
11. Plantar Fasciitis - StatPearls - NCBI Bookshelf, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK431073/
12. Treatment of Plantar Fasciitis | AAFP, https://www.aafp.org/pubs/afp/issues/2001/0201/p467.html
13. Metatarsalgia - Symptoms & causes - Mayo Clinic, https://www.mayoclinic.org/diseases-conditions/metatarsalgia/symptoms-causes/syc-20354790
14. Pain in the ball of your foot (metatarsalgia) and how to get relief - HealthPartners, https://www.healthpartners.com/blog/metatarsalgia-symptoms-treatment/
15. High Arched Feet (Cavus Foot): Causes and Treatment, https://www.verywellhealth.com/high-arched-feet-1337684
16. 4 Tips For Living With High Arches - Feet First Clinic, https://feetfirstclinic.com/blog/4-tips-for-living-with-high-arches/
17. Early Intervention in High Arch Feet Management: The Path to a Pain-Free Future, https://prokinetixrehab.com/post/early-intervention-in-high-arch-feet-management-the-path-to-a-pain-free-future/
18. cambridgephysio.ca, https://cambridgephysio.ca/blog/custom-orthotics-for-high-arches/#:~:text=Custom%20orthotics%20provide%20tailored%20support,on%20the%20heel%20and%20forefoot.
19. Custom Orthotics Can Prevent High Arch Pain - Blog, https://www.ccfootcare.com/blog/custom-orthotics-can-prevent-high-arch-pain
20. Mechanism of orthotic therapy for the painful cavus foot deformity, https://d-nb.info/1106910044/34
21. Mechanism of orthotic therapy for the painful cavus foot deformity ..., https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3924916/
22. Pes Cavus | PM&R KnowledgeNow, https://now.aapmr.org/pes-cavus/
23. (PDF) Effects of custom-made insoles on idiopathic pes cavus foot during walking, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282244465_Effects_of_custom-made_insoles_on_idiopathic_pes_cavus_foot_during_walking
24. Benefits of Arch Supports and Why You Should Wear Them, https://luckyfeetshoes.com/blogs/blog/benefits-arch-supports
25. What is EVA foam in shoes, and what are its pros and cons?, https://kanefootwear.com/blogs/kane-blog/what-is-eva-foam
26. How Orthotics Can Improve Balance and Prevent Falls, https://www.thefootlab.com/benefits-foot-lab/how-orthotics-can-improve-balance-and-prevent-falls/
27. Natural Foot Orthotics: Arch Support Inserts for Plantar Fasciitis, https://www.naturalfootorthotics.com/
28. How Deep Heel Cups Support Your Feet?, https://flowfeet.com/blog/post/13/how-deep-heel-cups-support-feet
29. Original Orthotic: High Arch Support Inserts - Natural Foot Orthotics, https://www.naturalfootorthotics.com/products/original-stabilizer
30. How Seniors Can Benefit from Foot Orthotics - Foot Care of Northeast Arkansas, https://www.footdoctorjonesboro.com/blog/item/596-how-seniors-can-benefit-from-foot-orthotics
31. The Benefits of Foot Orthotics for Older Adults, https://www.boyntonpodiatry.com/blog/item/552-the-benefits-of-foot-orthotics-for-older-adults.html
32. What Are Insoles Made Of? - Tread Labs, https://treadlabs.com/blogs/insoles-reach-your-stride/what-are-insoles-made-of
33. 20 Types of Arch Support, Inserts and Insoles for Your Feet - CareCredit, https://www.carecredit.com/well-u/health-wellness/types-of-arch-support-insoles-inserts/
34. The Misconceptions About Custom Orthotics | Manhattan Podiatrist, https://tohealthyfeet.com/blog/The+Misconceptions+About+Custom+Orthotics/81
35. Over-the-Counter Orthotics | Grayslake, IL, http://www.fixfeet.org/footwear/orthotics/over-the-counter-orthotics/
36. Best Materials for Orthotics: How and Why Orthotic Materials Differ ..., https://www.upstep.com/a/blog/best-materials-for-orthotics-how-and-why-orthotic-materials-differ
37. Pes Cavus Pathology | ProLab Orthotics, Inc., https://www.prolaborthotics.com/resource/pes-cavus-pathology/
38. All-Purpose Support High Arch: High Arch Orthotic Insoles | Superfeet, https://www.superfeet.com/products/all-purpose-support-high-arch
39. All-Purpose Support High Arch Insoles - Superfeet Worldwide, https://www.superfeet.eu/products/all-purpose-support-high-arch
40. All-Purpose Support High Arch: High Arch Orthotic Insoles | Superfeet, https://www.superfeet.com/en-us/all-purpose-support-high-arch
41. PowerStep Insoles for High Arches / Supination, https://powerstep.com/collections/high-arches-supination
42. PowerStep Pinnacle High Insoles | High Arch Pain Relief Orthotic, Supination Inserts, https://powerstep.com/products/pinnacle-high-arch-insoles
43. The Process of Getting Custom Made Orthotics, https://feetfirstortho.com/the-process-of-getting-custom-made-orthotics/
44. A Comprehensive Guide to Getting Fitted for Custom Orthotics, https://steadyfootclinic.ca/a-comprehensive-guide-to-getting-fitted-for-custom-orthotics/
45. Advice on Custom Orthotics from Non-Surgical Foot Specialists - HSS, https://www.hss.edu/health-library/move-better/custom-orthotics-advice
46. Foot Orthotics - Univera Healthcare, https://www.univerahealthcare.com/documents/d/global/uni-prv-foot-orthotics
47. What are the price ranges for good custom orthotic inserts? - Podiatry and Foot Pain Community - Upstep, https://www.upstep.com/a/community/orthotics/what-are-the-price-ranges-for-good-custom-orthotic-inserts
48. How Much Do Custom Orthotics Cost? - GoodRx, https://www.goodrx.com/conditions/musculoskeletal/custom-orthotics-cost
49. Custom orthotics vs. over-the-counter — it's about more than cost ..., https://www.greatbasinortho.com/articles/custom-orthotics-vs-over-counter-its-about-more-cost
50. Therapeutic shoes & inserts - Medicare, https://www.medicare.gov/coverage/therapeutic-shoes-inserts
51. Are the deep heel cup insoles comfortable? | Orthotics Insoles ..., https://www.aideastep.com/are-the-deep-heel-cup-insoles-comfortable/
52. Insole Guide: How to Choose the Right Insole – The Insole Store, https://theinsolestore.com/pages/insole-guide
53. Navigating the Different Types of Foot Orthotics - Gait Happens, https://gaithappens.com/types-of-foot-orthotics/
54. What is EVA foam, https://foamcreations.com/en/news/what-is-eva-foam-and-what-are-its-common-applications
55. Gel Insoles - Shoe Inserts for Heel, Foot or Arch Pain — Vive Health, https://www.vivehealth.com/products/gel-shoe-inserts
56. Orthotics and insoles for plantar fasciitis: Do they help, and are they worth it? - Exakt Health, https://www.exakthealth.com/en-US/blog/orthotics-insoles-for-plantar-fasciitis
57. How Do Metatarsal Pads Help Forefoot Pain? - Tread Labs, https://treadlabs.com/blogs/insoles-reach-your-stride/best-metatarsal-foot-pads
58. Metatarsal Pad Insoles: Can They Cure Your Foot Pain? - Custom ..., https://www.upstep.com/a/blog/metatarsal-pad-insoles-can-they-cure-your-foot-pain
59. Benefits of Orthotics for Metatarsal Pain, https://easyfeet.store/blogs/our-blog/benefits-of-orthotics-for-metatarsal-pain
60. Metatarsal Pad Benefits | Natural Footgear, https://naturalfootgear.com/blogs/educational-articles/metatarsal-pad-benefits
61. How to Break in Orthotics Pain-Free - Upstep Answers, https://www.upstep.com/a/answers/orthotics/how-to-break-in-orthotics-pain-free
62. What's the typical time period for breaking in custom orthotics ..., https://biocorrect.com/blogs/news/what-s-the-typical-time-period-for-breaking-in-custom-orthotics
63. How to use orthotics : r/BBallShoes - Reddit, https://www.reddit.com/r/BBallShoes/comments/tjapqi/how_to_use_orthotics/
64. Do I Remove Original Insoles When Using Orthotics Insoles?, https://alineinsoles.com/blogs/news/do-i-remove-original-insoles-when-using-orthotics-insoles
65. blog.insoles.com, https://blog.insoles.com/how-to-trim-your-insoles-in-4-simple-steps/#:~:text=Place%20the%20insole%20in%20your,There%20you%20have%20it!
66. Properly Fitting Your Orthotics Into Your Shoes - Sports Performance - San Francisco Podiatrist, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CQrgEXMDfqo
67. How to Trim Superfeet Insoles to Perfectly Fit Your Running Shoes - YouTube, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VMLPCTRCa_E
68. How to Choose Orthotics | Nationwide Children's Hospital, https://www.nationwidechildrens.org/specialties/sports-medicine/sports-medicine-articles/how-to-choose-orthotics
69. The 10 Best Walking Shoes for High Arches, Tested - Verywell Fit, https://www.verywellfit.com/best-walking-shoes-for-high-arches-4428043
70. Best High Arches and High Instep Shoes, https://www.healthyfeetstore.com/collections/high-arches-and-high-instep-shoes